Welcome to my world.

My blog is one place where I can be myself without worrying about my voice being too loud, my laugh too raucous or my ideas too weird.

Twenty- five Seven

Personally speaking

Child of Misfortune – A detective novel that fails to thrill.

This review is a part of the biggest <a href=”http://blog.blogadda.com/2011/05/04/indian-bloggers-book-reviews” target=”_blank”> Book Review Program </a> for <a href=”http://www.blogadda.com” target=”_blank”>Indian Bloggers.</a> Participate now to get free books!

Meet  Amit Pratap Rathore, a
barely  5 foot something child of
privilege who is known for not sitting for his Board exams, abandoning his
quest of Mount Everest, giving up his startup company – in short, famous for
starting something and not seeing it through. 
Also meet the inscrutable super
achiever who is part French and part Indian – Jonah Michel who joins school in
the graduating year and poses the greatest threat to Amit Pratap Rathore’s
unchallenged supremacy in chess, swimming and debating, thereby sowing the seeds of lifelong rivalry.
Also meet Mansi Agarwal , friend to
both  who grows up to become a
journalist and meet Kang,  a 19
year old social engineer or hacker operating out of Seoul, Korea.
To this add some more random
characters like Bubujika Makinda from East Africa and Dame Loretta Quin among
others; some  detailed descriptions of exotic locales like Leh, Seoul, the
City of London; stir in some good old schoolboy rivalry; a smattering of deep knowledge of terrorism, drug
dealing, money laundering, hacking ; garnish with some romance and violence and
you have a potboiler that is supposed to keep you spell bound to the last page.
Sadly though, this book fails at some level to keep you enthralled. Despite the good language, and thorough background research the characters don’t ring true and the story seems terribly contrived. This first book by Soumitra Singh ends up looking more like a Hardy Boys clone
rather than a sophisticated thriller in the manner of Ludlum  and Forsyth. The story starts with Amar landing up in Leh
supposedly to track down Mansi and takes us back in the past to their life in Bombay after the gruesome decapitation of a Buddhist monk, the theft of the Prophet’s Hair an unsuccessful suicide bomb attack and the destruction of an
Al Qaeda camp near the Siachin glacier. These seemingly unrelated incidents are
part of an international conspiracy of drug dealing and money laundering all eventually tying in with a larger terrorist plan. Somehow
Jonah gets wind of this and lures Amar, the bleeding heart idealist, to help him bring the
culprits to book. 

While all of this doesn’t seem improbable, what is hard to believe is the proficiency of these young detectives: at age 16, Jonah is an accomplished chess player
and a proficient killer who cold bloodedly gets rid of his enemies. It is no
surprise then that by the age of 21 he is fluent in Kashmiri and Czech, an
expert in martial arts and weaponry, a computer whiz and a financial
consultant! Amar too, seems to be another whizz kid with  a razor sharp mind that allows him to understand the
entire Kashmir problem in a mere 7 hour session at an Internet café and figure out
the exits in a building that he has just entered a few seconds earlier!


This is a brave first attempt but unfortunately “The Child of Misfortune”  is an exercise in futility. Perhaps this book will
appeal more to young adults rather than old timers like me and I’d rather wait
till Soumitra Singh  grows up and finds his place in the sun. 

Enhanced by Zemanta

Discover more from Twenty- five Seven

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a comment

Discover more from Twenty- five Seven

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started